Argumentative Essay For A Rose For Emily

To reinforce this argument, Dilworth argues that the traits and behaviors of Emily are creations of the narrator thus implying that he presents Emily as the symbol of communicating what he believes to be the cultural values of the society in which he lives.Arguably, therefore, the actions of the main character such as killing followed by evading justice and failure to pay taxes without any legal action being taken upon her are depictive of the eminent shortfalls of the white society of the south during the time of writing of the short story.

Tags: Iep Case Study AutismTerm Paper ServiceEssay On Effects Of Television And ComputersThesis Statement Of A Research PaperArgumentative Essay PapersExample Of Library Research PaperEssay On Being A Good TeacherRobert E Lee EssayOedipus Tiresias EssayComposition Essay Prompts

For instance, he argues that the fact that Emily and Barron lived together before they were legally married implied that the society engaged in fornication yet people like Emily were Christians.

In this context, Dilworth claims that Emily “chose to enter into collusion with the society to the extent of maintaining her image as a proper high-class southern Christian” (Dilworth, 1999, p.255).

While it could be possible for the four men to suspect that the smell should have emanated from a large corpse, it is also important to note that they could have possibly suspected that the corpse was of a human being if the men knew that Emily had the capacity to kill.

This is only possible if they had the experience of situations in which Emily had killed people and buried them secretly.

However, in linking Emily with the death of Barron, Dilworth uses evidence from the story to prove his argument.

For instance, he quotes the townspeople’s knowledge of the last time that they saw Barron enter his lover’s house by arguing out, “they knew that her lover was last seen entering at the kitchen door at dusk one evening” (Dilworth , 1999, p.258).

The themes of change are reflected by Miss Emily’s denial of the fate of death and refusal to comply with the obligation for paying taxes.

In this perspective, Dilworth argues that the killing of Homer Barron “is eclipsed in the imagination of readers by evidence of some sort of necrophilia” (1999, p. The focus of this paper is to analyze the article, in terms of logicalness of the presented arguments coupled with giving the writer’s response to the article.

However, Dilworth maintains that he believes that the society never knew about the evils of Emily until her death, and a rotting corpse was found by the side of an indent of a woman with Emily’s hair resting on it.

However, he also raises several counterarguments including the knowledge of the townspeople that she had bought arsenic, which, if she was to take it, could have made her kill herself (p.269).


Comments Argumentative Essay For A Rose For Emily

The Latest from ©