In addition to supporting your thesis, you are letting your instructor know how carefully you read. If you write in your essay that you are unconvinced by an author’s assertions about the civility of American politics, you should be ready to raise your hand in class to point to the relevant passage and to ask if your classmates had the same reaction.
In addition to supporting your thesis, you are letting your instructor know how carefully you read. If you write in your essay that you are unconvinced by an author’s assertions about the civility of American politics, you should be ready to raise your hand in class to point to the relevant passage and to ask if your classmates had the same reaction.Tags: Classification Advertisement EssaysTable Assignment CardsReading Homework HelpCauses Of Wwi EssaySwot Analysis EssayHeader Graphic Thesis ThemePro Choice Essays On AbortionPersuasive Essays On Social MediaEssay Arrangement
Since the whole class has read the same book, summary is unnecessary.
Rather, the response is a chance for you to work out your thoughts about a book on paper, before the discussion itself.
If you’re feeling particularly organized, you can use the type of notes called KWL.
These letters stand for what you Know, what you Want to know and what you will Learn after you read the text.
In Sherry’s case, a simple check of page references shows how he has reordered Gaddis’s facts and words to suit his purpose. Unless a book’s format is important to your argument, you need not comment on its typography, the choice of footnotes vs. Comments on writing style and the use of illustrations may be important, but only if they support your thesis.
And even arguments and facts that are very important to the book’s author may not be important to your essay.September 2005 Professors who wish to force students to not only read assigned texts but to think about them as well may assign reading responses.A reading response is an essay about a book, and like any essay, it must argue a thesis.Gaddis argues that Cold War American policy-makers “were projecting abroad a tradition they had long taken for granted at home: that civility made sense; that spontaneity . In lamenting the lack of evidence for Gaddis’s assertions, Sherry takes Gaddis on his own terms and shows that more work must be done.One of my students aptly termed this a “yes, but” approach.And applying what you have learned in one course to another course makes your education more than a collection of unrelated topics. A reading response is not like the commentary track on a DVD, in which a director watches the film and says whatever pops into his mind.If anything, it is more like a trailer for the film, in which short clips are presented in a new order, for another result.A good response should address one or more issues that are central to understanding the book, but it need not address all such issues.You are approaching the book from one angle, perhaps emphasizing just one theme. I generally assign reading responses to prepare students for discussion classes.In the example, Sherry wants to prove that Gaddis should have paid more attention to race and gender.Using one book from a course to understand a later book in the course makes the course into something more than a collection of discrete texts.